The Holy Spirit
What is the Holy Spirit? Is the Holy Spirit equal to the Father and the Son? Is the Holy Spirit the third person in the divine being? What does the whole counsel of Scripture teach us concerning the Holy Spirit?
As a resourceful help to this phase of our study,
Yahweh's Assembly in Yahshua has published an awesome treatise entitled '
The Truth about the Trinity.' It contains a well-rounded overview of what the apostolic scriptures teach about the Holy Spirit. It is also recommended reading to the student of the Bible. However, I have chosen to include in this section many quotations from this work because the level of research and scholarship is absolutely phenomenal as you will see.
From the onset, let's reiterate a biblical principle mentioned at the close of our discussion regarding the Son. 'Every matter must be established by the testimony of two or three witnesses,' Deuteronomy 19:15, 2 Corinthians 13:1, and John 8:17-18. Without looking any further, we can conclude that Scripture contains at least three witnesses to the fact that the Holy Spirit is not a person. Apostle Peter, Paul and Luke all referred to the Holy Spirit as being neuter in gender in the King James Version Bible. See 1 Peter 1:11; Romans 8:16, 26; and Acts 2:3. They referred to the Holy Spirit as 'it' or 'itself' rather than 'He' or 'Him'.
Some have argued in Acts 13:2 that the Holy Spirit actually spoke to the Apostle Paul and therefore is a third person deity. The fact that Yahweh caused Balaam's donkey to speak to him doesn't make his donkey a person nor god anymore than the Holy Spirit can be said to be a person because Yahweh causes it to speak. See Numbers 22:28.
Now let's consider some of the excerpts taken from
Yahweh's Assembly in Yahshua aforementioned exposition entitled '
The Truth about the Trinity.'
Under subtitle, p. 7,'Spirit is a Force[:] Spirit is translated from the Hebrew ruach and occurs 389 times in the Old Testament. It is rendered spirit 237 times in the King James Version. The Companion Bible says that the basic idea running through all the passages is 'invisible force.' In whatever sense the word ruach is used, it means an unseen force except by its manifestations. It can be compared to a physical force like magnetism, gravity, and in our modern age, electricity and radioactivity. The Bible likens spirit to wind.
'In the New Testament Greek text spirit is pneuma and carries the same meaning—in Greek it means to breathe. …Is it any wonder that following His resurrection, Yahshua gave the Holy Spirit to His disciples when 'he breathed on them,' John 20:22? Heavenly power came from His nostrils, not a person! Both ruach and pneuma mean 'wind.' They can also mean the invisible, vital force in living creatures, or a dominant feeling, attitude or disposition. Spirit can refer to the invisible world, including Yahweh and His angelic creatures, as well as the evil, satanic realm. It can also refer to Yahweh's holy, active, or life-giving force or power.
'All of these meanings have the sense of an active vitality that is invisible to human eyes. We cannot see spirit just as we cannot 'see' wind, gravity, radio waves, electricity, or magnetism. But we can see what it does, the results of its activity. We can often see the effects of the special power of Yahweh's Holy Spirit, too.'
Under subtitle, p. 15, 'The Holy Spirit's Nonperson, Inanimate Attributes [:] The invisible power or force which flows from Yahweh is unseen, and is often treated as a material substance. The spirit is POURED out (Isaiah 32:15, 44:3; Acts 2:17); SHED (Titus 3:5-6; Acts 2:33); BREATHED (John 20:22); and it FILLED people (Acts 2:2-4; Ephesians 5:18). Yahshua Himself was ANOINTED with the Spirit (Acts 10:38) and men were BAPTIZED with it (Matthew 3:11).
'Is it possible for a person to be 'poured out' on other people? If the Spirit is properly recognized as a force or energy, then the correct sense of the Spirit's empowering the people to abide by Yahweh's Law is understood, especially if they are filled with that spirit poured out on them.
'We read that Yahweh anointed Yahshua of Nazareth with the Holy Spirit in Acts 10:38. This act is incomprehensible if we accept the pagan teaching that the Holy Spirit is a person equal to the Father and the Son. Why and how could this co-equal, in-power person be poured upon the Son who was equal in power?
'If we properly understand the Spirit to be force or energy, (power) poured upon the Son, saturating Him as with oil, then we truly grasp the Biblical meaning of 'spirit' and see why Yahshua is called the Messiah, Yahweh's 'anointed' (anointed means to rub with oil).'
Under subtitle, p. 16, 'Holy Spirit Symbolized Yahweh's Attributes [:] The Holy Spirit is an invisible, holy, flowing energy coming from the Heavenly Father and shared by His Son, Yahshua. The Spirit, force or power accomplishes their will.
'At times Yahweh refers to His Spirit as power, an attitude, a pervading force, a powerful vitality, a dynamic influence that comes from Him. His Spirit, emanating from Himself, helps us reach a standard of righteousness and so influences behavior that at times it is seen as almost a living vitality, as evident from the following verses:
''
And Yahweh said, My Spirit shall not always strive with man, for that he also [is] flesh: yet his days shall be an hundred and twenty years.' (Genesis 6:3)
''
But Peter, said, Ananias, why has Satan filled your heart to lie to the Holy Spirit, and to keep back [part] of the price of the land?' (Acts 5:3)
''
The Spirit itself bears witness with our spirit, that we are the children of Elohim.' (Romans 8:16)
'Those who don't understand this metaphoric usage, as simply an extension of Yahweh Himself, leap to the conclusion that He is talking of another Being.
'
The New Schaff-Herzog Religious Encyclopedia explains that although Scripture uses terms like grieved in reference to the Holy Spirit, the terminology should not be taken for a separate person. 'A similar concept underlines the Johannine terms teaching, reproving, and declaring, as applied to the personal Paraclete. Nonetheless, to interpret these passages as implying a person distinct from G-d and Chr-st, whose Spirit he is called, is not warranted.' (Trinity, Doctrine of, p.19)'
Under subtitle, p. 9, ''Proof' Texts to Support Trinity [:] An attempt to 'prove' a Trinity is I John 5:7. However, newer Bible translations have corrected this spurious verse. The Catholic Jerusalem Bible says in a footnote to I John 5:7, 'Not in any of the early Greek manuscripts, or any of the early translations, or in the best manuscripts of the Vulgate itself.' This bogus text reads: 'For there are three that bear record in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Spirit: these three are one.'
'
The Companion Bible states that this verse was not found in any Greek manuscripts before the 16th century but was first seen in the margins of some of the Latin copies: from there it crept into the text. Modern translations do not include this verse in the main body of their text but may have a footnote stating that this verse is spurious. It is plainly a forgery inserted by some Trinitarian zealot during the Dark Ages.'
Under the subtitle, p. 12, 'Grammatical gender Mistaken for the Literal [:] Another so called 'proof' often presented to show that the Holy Spirit is a sentient being is that the personal pronouns He, Him or His often refer to the spirit in the English Scriptures. John 14:17 is misused to force a personality aspect on the Holy Spirit: '[Even] the Spirit of truth; whom the world cannot receive, because it sees HIM not, neither knows HIM: but you know HIM; for HE dwells with you, and shall be in you' (John 14:17).
'The use of the personal pronoun WHOM in this text is unwarranted, reflecting simply the translator's prejudice. WHICH better renders the Greek neuter from. The Greek pronoun in auto, and refers back to Comforter (Greek=Parakletos), which is a noun of masculine gender, and apparently the reason translators provided the 'Him' and 'He' pronouns.
'Understand that nouns in most European languages have gender. To English-speaking peoples this is a rather peculiar characteristic of their languages. For example, in German 'plate' and 'fork' are feminine. In French 'knife' is masculine and 'fork' feminine. It would be as logical to insist that 'fork' is a person—because fork is feminine in German and French— as it would be to claim that the comforter is a person because Parakletos (comforter) is masculine in Greek. Pronouns must agree in number, case, and gender. English is not nearly so sophisticated in its grammar.
'The Greek word for spirit (pneuma) is neuter in gender and properly should be translated it. Some translations do not follow the King James in referring to the spirit as He but more properly it. These Bibles are the Diaglott (a literal translation from the Greek), Rotherham, Literal Concordant, and Goodspeed, among others. Pronouns referring to spirit are also neuter. But those referring to the Father and the Son are masculine.
'In contrast to the Greek, Hebrew nouns have no neuter gender. In Hebrew, nouns are either masculine or feminine. Therefore, while ruach (spirit) is masculine in gender, according to rules of Hebrew grammar, the religion of Judaism does NOT look upon ruach as a person, but as a POWER or FORCE.'
Finally, under the subtitle, p. 17, 'Scriptural Synopsis of Holy Spirit Facts [:] Not all the following statements have been explained fully within this brief booklet, yet are important to consider in regard to a Trinity doctrine supposedly supported by the Scriptures:
'*The Greek philosopher Plato and the Alexandrine Platonists are the source of the modern trinity doctrine.
'Author Alvan Lamson elaborates on the doctrine of the Trinity on page 34 of The Church of the First Three Centuries: '…we must look, not to the Jewish Scriptures, nor to the teachings of [Yahshua] and his apostles, but to Philo [the Jewish philosopher of the first century C. E.] and the Alexandrine Platonists. In consistency with this view, we maintain that the doctrine of the Trinity was a gradual and comparatively late formation; that it had its origin in a source entirely foreign from that of Jewish and Christian Scriptures; that it grew up, and was engrafted on Christianity, through the hands of the Platonizing fathers…'
'*The apostate church about the fourth century accepted the Trinity, which was then passed on to her daughters. Acceptance of a Triune deity was influenced by the polytheistic ('having many deities') worship everywhere extant among heathen peoples.
'*Neither the term trinity nor its doctrine is found in either the Old or New Testaments.
'*The Holy Spirit (erroneous 'Ghost') is not a person.
'*
Ruach (Hebrew) and
pneuma (Greek) are the Hebrew and Greek from which we get Holy Spirit in our Bibles. They have as their root meaning 'wind or breath' in both the Hebrew and Greek.
'*The Holy Spirit is that invisible force of energy flowing from the Father and Son. It might be likened to the rays of the sun that give us light and heat. The rays are not the sun, but are the power from the sun.
'*Personal pronouns referring to the Holy Spirit do not make it a person any more than Yahshua's telling Peter to put the sword back into 'HIS' place makes the sword a male person (Matthew 26:52).
'*The Spirit can be 'shed' (Acts 2:33), 'poured' (Acts 2:17), 'breathed' (John 20:22), 'stirred up' (2 Timothy 1:6), 'quenched' (I Thes. 5:19), 'renewed' (2 Cor. 4:16)—all of which are literally incompatible with a person or being.
'*The Father and Son converse with each other, but do not talk to the Spirit.
'*Nowhere is the spirit prayed to. If the Holy Spirit were a person, then the Holy Spirit would be Yahshua's father and not Yahweh. Notice how Yahshua was conceived in the flesh:
''
But while he thought on these things, behold, the angel of Yahweh appeared unto him in a dream, saying, Joseph, you son of David, fear not to take unto you Mary your wife: for that which is conceived in her is of the Holy Spirit' (Matthew 1:20). Yet Yahshua called Yahweh His Father, not the Holy Spirit. He was conceived by and through the power of Yahweh—making Yahweh His Father.
'*Scripture never calls the Holy Spirit the 'third person'.
'*Salutations found in the first verse of two of the Epistles by Paul, Peter, and John mention Father and Son, but not Spirit.
'*In his Epistles Paul greets the brethren in the name of Yahweh and Yahshua. Never in the opening of his letters does Paul ever greet anyone 'in the Name of the Holy Spirit.' Not a person, the Holy Spirit has no name as do Yahweh and Yahshua. For example, Ephesians 1:2 reads, '
Grace [be] to you, and peace, from Yahweh our Father, and from the Savior Yahshua the Messiah.'
'*The Biblical meaning of being 'one' means being in accord, harmony, of like mind, united in goals. Not being one personage.
'*Elohim, used for the Heavenly Majesty, is a collective noun, and does not specifically mean 'three.' It simply means more than one, a plurality.
'*Examples given in the Bible show the Father on a throne: Ezekiel 1:26; Daniel 7:9; Acts 7:55-56; Rev. 4:2; 5:1, 7; 20:11, etc… The Holy Spirit is not given a throne (but indwells us, as it did Stephen, Acts 7:55).